View this film to find out why insulation resistance (IR) is important to the operation of your subsea electrical system.
WHAT IS IR & WHY IS IT IMPORTANT?
Every electric wire is covered with some form of electrical insulation, whereas the wire itself is usually copper, which is a good conductor of the electric current that powers the equipment. The insulation must be just the opposite from a conductor: it should resist current and keep the current in its path along the conductor. Note, however, that no insulation is perfect so some electricity does flow through the insulation to ground.
‘Good’ insulation means a relatively high resistance to current and also the ability to maintain that high resistance over time. So, measuring insulation resistance (typically referred to as ‘IR’) regularly could indicate how “good” the insulation is and can also check trends toward its deterioration.
While regulations vary throughout the world, the facts about the deterioration of cables, especially those located on the seabed, do not. The physics remain the same. Any electrical insulation will begin to deteriorate after it is made. The environment in which the subsea cable lies, however, is particularly harsh and the conditions will almost certainly increase the rate of deterioration. If the subsea cable insulation becomes compromised it increases the risks of equipment failure (and so lost production).
Insulation resistance needs to be maintained at safe levels to not only shield against loss of production but also to protect against electric shocks to humans.
When your cables, connectors and umbilicals are new, the electrical insulation should be in excellent condition. Nevertheless, insulation is subject to many effects which can cause it to fail – electrical stresses, mechanical damage, moisture or general ageing. As pinholes or cracks develop, water will penetrate the surfaces of the insulation, providing a low resistance path for leakage current.
Sometimes the drop in insulation resistance is sudden, but usually, it drops gradually, giving plenty of warning, if checked periodically. Good insulation has high resistance; poor insulation, relatively low resistance, but what really matters is the trend in readings over a time period, showing lessening resistance and warning of impending problems.
HOW IS IT MONITORED?
For subsea cables, the traditional cost of maintenance and repair is extremely high. Continuous monitoring helps to provide a clearer picture of trends in insulation resistance so operators can make better strategic decisions.
Floating earth systems (known as IT or Isolation Terra) are commonly used as they promote the high availability of the system – a vital consideration for subsea networks. Such systems continue to work even if there is a single fault to ground. Although systems still operate and production can continue, a second insulation fault can result in dangerously high leakage currents that could present a high risk of an electric shock on human contact. A second earth fault can also lead to an accelerated failure of the electrical system through the erosion of the copper conductors as a result of current leakage and the electrochemical reaction of the copper in the seawater.
WHY DO I NEED ONE?
Fundamentally, it is the integrity of the insulation material that prevents a potentially fatal risk to personnel from leakage currents and also maintains the delivery of the electrical power and communications that are needed to maintain the hydrocarbon production.
Current through and along insulation is made up partly of a relatively steady current in leakage paths over the insulation surface. Electricity also flows through the volume of the insulation. The total leakage current comprises three components:
- Capacitance Charging Current: Current that starts out high and drops after the insulation has been charged to full voltage.
- Absorption Current: Also an initially high current which then drops (for reasons discussed under the section Time-Resistance Method).
- Conduction or Leakage Current: A small essentially steady current both through and over the insulation.
HOW DOES A LIM WORK?
In Alternating Current (AC) IT systems, the measured leakage current depends only on line-to-ground insulation parameters of single conductors and not of the wire-to-wire insulation.
A device that is used for monitoring leakage current and therefore, indirectly, the insulation resistance is commonly known as a Line Insulation Monitor (LIM) or an Insulation Monitoring Device (IMD). From here on we will just use the LIM terminology. A LIM can use a range of measurement techniques to find the leakage current and detect the magnitude of the failure in the insulation. The leakage current is measured by applying a fixed DC (Direct Current) voltage, a low-frequency AC voltage, a combination of the two, or a series of positive and negative going square-wave pulses. The leakage current that results from this applied measurement signal can be converted into an impedance to ground (impedance being the opposition of electrical current flow in an AC circuit). Depending on the capability of the LIM, the output measurement will either be just the leakage resistance (insulation resistance) or it could also include the leakage capacitance – as per the capacitive charging current.
If the measured impedance decreases below a predetermined value, due to a first fault to ground, a local and a remotely enunciated alarm will be initiated.
What is often not fully appreciated is the benefit of being able to monitor the integrity of the insulation material of the electrical cables from the initial installation, when the insulation is known to be good, and not just monitoring it when the cable is close to failure (a low insulation resistance). A new cable is ideally commissioned with an IR value in excess of 1GΩ. Over-time there will be some IR degradation due to the hygroscopic properties of some of the insulation material and also due to any manufacturing flaws or inclusions coupled with the fact that the cable is in a seawater environment. By measuring the full range of IR, a declining IR trend can be identified earlier in the degradation process.
The majority of LIMs on the market, have a relatively low range of measurement with a maximum measurement capability of 10MΩ – clearly unable to measure any degradation until the insulation resistance has dropped to a level below this maximum measurement capability. Newer offerings to the market have far higher ranges, but generally, there is a trade-off with measurement accuracy and measurement repeatability at the lower end of the measurement range. Measurement at the low end is where it is critical to both production and personnel safety. Ideally, therefore, the LIM should have the high-performance capability at the ‘low end’ of its measurement range but have a capability to measure insulation resistance at 1GΩ, albeit at reduced accuracy. For the monitoring of subsea installations, a measurement range of higher than 1GΩ provides very little added value since this would typically be the level of insulation resistance presented to the LIM for a newly installed subsea system. Any change in measurements above 1GΩ could be as a result of the LIM measurement accuracy just as much as a change in the condition of the insulation. In addition, no decisions or plans would be made in practice as long as the insulation reading was in the hundreds of MΩ. It is therefore important that the LIM selection is made on the needs of the monitoring function rather than just selecting on the highest measurement value quoted on the data sheet – ‘bigger isn’t better’ when it comes to LIMs.
Existing topside LIMs only provide a single insulation resistance measurement for the complete subsea system. When the IR drops, the LIM provides no information on the number of faults or their location. The IR alone does not tell the operator which component is at fault and resolution of an issue often requires a costly and time-consuming diagnostic campaign. However, modern technology offers operators a solution to this challenge. LIM devices are now available that can be installed subsea to form a distributed LIM network that communicates back to a topside monitoring device. These units measure the IR of the entire system but critically they can also determine the IR upstream and downstream of their location. By placing these in strategic locations in the subsea network, a complete subsea distribution system electrical integrity map is created; giving operators not only information about the general insulation integrity beneath the water but also the information required to reduce the cost of maintenance and repairs. Indeed, having the visibility of which leg of the subsea system is failing offers a huge financial gain. Knowing where a fault lies, also reduces the number of disconnects required during the fault-finding process and so reduces the risk of introducing additional faults or weaknesses in the system.